On the Fourth of July in 1903, at least 1,400 people made the trip north from Prescott to a swimming lake in the boulders. The Weekly Journal-Miner wrote that "every rig in town seemed to be pressed into service to carry visitors there," and the night closed with fireworks. The destination was the Granite Dells Resort, at the end of Granite Dells Road off what is now Highway 89, and it stayed open as a summer resort until 1971.
The resort buildings still stand on private land. Right next to them is something any Granite Dells resident can visit this weekend: a 28-acre city preserve with a trail that follows the old ditch that once carried Granite Creek water to the resort's swimming hole.
A homestead at Point of Rocks
The story begins with the Wing family. In the early 1880s, James Wing filed a homestead on 160 acres about five miles north of Prescott, in an area then called Point of Rocks. According to the Sharlot Hall Museum's Days Past history, his father Thomas Wing came up with the name "Granite Dells," because the homestead held a small, secluded valley full of woods and wildlife. The Wings farmed the valley and improved an old pond and irrigation system they found on the land.
In 1885, Marcia Wing married E. C. Payne. That marriage joined the two families whose names still mark this corner of Prescott. After her brother James and her father Thomas both died, Marcia Wing Payne inherited the Granite Dells property. By 1903 the valley was already known as Prescott's summer resort, with picnicking, bathing, boating and dancing under a canvas-covered pavilion.
Two seasons under Ed Shumate
The man who made the resort pay was a businessman named Ed Shumate. Prescott LIVING magazine's history of the resort says he signed a lease in April 1903 and had a little over two weeks to get ready for opening. He added a billiards room, a bowling alley, a baseball field, a dancing platform and what the paper called an "excellent eating house," and later built a pavilion that seated 300 to 400 people. Families escaping the desert heat could rent tents by the week or by the month.
Before the 1904 season, Shumate made the lake larger and deeper. Opening day that year had a bronco riding exhibition, a concert, and the season's first baseball game, Prescott against Iron King. At the end of the school year he let local children use the amusements for free, and ordinary weekends drew 500 to 700 people.
Holidays drew far bigger crowds. Arizona Highways cites a Journal-Miner article from September 7, 1904, that called that year's Labor Day celebration the "most elaborate," with an estimated 1,000 to 1,500 people. Visitors came by train from Jerome and McCabe.
That same June, a fire before dawn destroyed the lodging house, the pavilions, the billiard room and the bowling alley. Parts of the resort reopened the following Sunday, and the place was almost fully back in order for the Fourth of July two weeks later. Early in 1905, Shumate sold the business to James Adams for $3,000, which Prescott LIVING put at about $86,500 in 2020 dollars.
The Payne brothers' pool
Ownership of the resort passed to the Payne family in the early 1920s. After World War I, Marcia's sons Morris and Howell Payne took over its management under the name "Outing Association." In 1922 they used their wartime service money to dig the mud and dirt out of the old swimming lake and build a cement pool said to hold three million gallons of water.
The resort held bathing beauty contests even before the pool was built. An entry in E. C. Payne's diary for June 15, 1921, reads: "1st Bathing Beauty Contest at Granite Dells swimming lake declared a gorgeous success." In June 1924 the Pessimist Club of Prescott sponsored a larger contest and invited the whole town to take part, "anyone from 9 to 90." The Sharlot Hall Museum Archives still hold photographs of those contests at the Granite Dells swimming lake.
From the 1930s through the 1970s the resort had a swimming pool, a boating lake, a dance pavilion, a shooting gallery, a bowling alley, food concessions and cottages. The setting brought in filmmakers too. Prescott Creeks describes the boulders, the tall cottonwoods and Granite Creek as the backdrop for Tom Mix films and for the movie Leave Her to Heaven.
Morris Payne closed the resort in 1971. The Sharlot Hall history cites the high cost of liability insurance as one reason.
The water system behind the swimming hole
The Wing farm, the Shumate lake and the Payne pool all relied on the same thing, and that system is the part you can still walk. Crops in this area were watered from Granite Creek through a network of ditches that began at a small diversion dam near the southern end of what is now the Watson Dam Trail. In its Winter 2013 newsletter, the Central Arizona Land Trust described the trail as closely following the old ditch's path, with bits of the concrete that once lined it visible along the way. About three-tenths of a mile from Granite Dells Road it passed an abandoned cement diversion box. That box sent water to crops on the far side of Granite Creek and also filled the Granite Gardens Lake and the swimming hole at the resort.
The land the trail crosses has its own Payne history. In 2002, Sherman Payne sold the 28.26-acre parcel that is now the Payne-Granite Dells Open Space to the Trust for Public Land. The Trust conveyed it to the City of Prescott in 2005, paid for through the 1% sales tax extension that voters approved in 2000. The Central Arizona Land Trust holds a conservation easement on the preserve, and the land is set aside for public hiking, biking and birding. The family that dug the pool in 1922 is the same family whose sale created the public ground next to it.
Walking it now
To get there, drive north out of downtown on Highway 89 and turn right onto Granite Dells Road. Prescott Creeks described the road in 2012 as ending right at the old resort. The Watson Dam Trail starts on Granite Dells Road, runs through the middle of the Payne preserve, and connects to the city's other open-space trails in the Dells. The city's current trail map shows the Watson Dam and Flume trails, and newer trails from that area now link to the Peavine. That makes the old resort's ditch one more way into the trail network that runs behind the neighborhood. We covered how that network came together in our earlier post on the Granite Dells trails.
The resort buildings stand on separate private land, and the trail does not go onto that land. Prescott LIVING reported in August 2020 that the resort site was still private property and that the lake had filled in and dried up. Preservation advocates have wanted the parcel for a long time. The Prescott Daily Courier once reported that it had "held the number-one spot on open-space priority lists for years." Stay on the trail inside the preserve, and look for the concrete along the ditch line. The Land Trust described those pieces in 2013, and they are the remains of the system that filled Prescott's favorite swimming hole for most of a century.
If you live in Granite Dells and want to know where your home stands today, Cheryl Fernandez would be glad to talk it through. Request your personalized home valuation, and we'll include the trails and preserves near your street in the conversation.